Don’t Call Me A Worship Leader

Elias Dummer —  March 26, 2014

The following post first appeared on Orthodoxical. Be sure to check it out and read more from Elias.

Have you seen this video?

Yes, it’s an ad, but the fact is that it points to a very real phenomenon. Our words do matter. And I have a concern with the way that we use a couple of particular words: I don’t want to be called a ‘worship leader’ anymore.

In between working as Worship Arts Director at a church and The City Harmonic becoming a full-time job for me I ran a small marketing company. And if I learned anything at all in that time it’s that our ideas, our habits and our words really do matter. I learned that a lot of effort and resources have been spent studying the mind – how we make decisions, what governs some of our instinctual actions, etc. Studies have shown that our brains live in something like a state of constant rewiring. The term they use to describe this is ‘neuroplasticity’: older, unused pathways in our mind dissolve and new ones, with repetition and focus, are formed. All the time. What we think about and say actually changes the way that our brains physically function. How we use our words has a direct effect on our response to stimuli. Like the video suggests, a small change in wording can radically alter the appeal and perception of just about anything. Suffice it to say that language effects how we view the ideas we attempt to describe and help us to form expectations of the world around us.

So what are we talking about when we use the phrase ‘worship leader’?

Now, I’m very grateful for the many resources – books, magazines and websites alike – that have emerged over the past twenty or thirty years, all of them aimed to equip churches in what’s commonly called the “worship renewal” movement or “contemporary worship”. But over time we’ve also seen a gradual shift towards the practical ‘equipping’ of musicians based on demand for tools just like this. And it seems to me that this and other factors have led to a very powerful word association — not just with music in general, but a particular style of music.

We Evangelicals have come to view the word ‘worship’ as referring to something like God-focused music. And music is inherently emotional. So it follows that our understanding of ‘worship’ could then be reduced to the personal expression of a God-centered, emotional experience. This then shapes our expectations in a church setting.

We come to Church with closed eyes, I often describe is as “a grouping of islands in a dark sea”, seeking these individual and transcendent emotional experiences. This may, at least in part, explain why people increasingly feel as though they don’t need the corporate expression of church to worship God at all – they can pop in a CD and have emotional experiences like this at home or have personal ‘spiritual’ experiences wherever they like. But it’s kind of like skipping leg day at the gym – the end result is that we end up looking unhealthy despite all the time we seem to spend ‘working out’.

This powerful word association of ‘worship’ and ‘music’ could also cause us to disassociate other important and traditional elements of Christian worship services (reading the word aloud, engaging in teaching within community, corporate prayer, serving, the creeds, the eucharist, fellowship) as not necessarily worshipful because they aren’t always personal, emotive expressions. This doesn’t seem right to me at all.  And the reason is that the end of worship isn’t our experience at all. It is God’s glory – but how? Simply by us saying, or singing, so?

‘The glory of God is man fully alive.’

– Irenaeus

Tim Keller explains that worship is the “act of ascribing ultimate value to something in a way that energizes and engages your whole person or being.” Worshiping God takes place in the active redirection of our love away from ourselves or our ideologies and towards Christ — including emotions, but also will, intellect, action – our whole selves! This is true when we sing, but also when we sit to learn, or shake the hand of a brother, or take communion.

Christian worship is incarnational (God-on-earth to redeem) not transcendent (we escape this troublesome old world to find God elsewhere).

It is formative (God changes us through our embodied practices) not just informative (we change ourselves as a result of God’s good ideas)

It’s embodied, not just expressed.

The fact is that as we gather together God’s presence transforms our lives, our spaces, our minds and hearts and our very selves from toe-to-top. Our meetings and liturgies in their entirety — and our shared mission when we leave — are like Kingdom trenches in a world at war with itself and badly in need of redemption. And so our ‘worship’ should reflect those same holistic values. The moment we intentionally or unintentionally prescribe a hierarchy of experiences (mind over matter, emotion over mind, actions over either) – we teeter dangerously on popular heresy.

So let’s be sure to constantly remind ourselves, starting with something as simple as our words, that ‘worship’ occurs in actively embodying our beliefs day-to-day, moment-to-moment, and accordingly describes the entirety of our worship services. Worship includes the redemption of our emotions (music), intellect (teaching/word), soul/will (prayer/fellowship) and bodies (eucharist/communion).

So, call me a ‘musical worship leader’, even just ‘musician’, but not ‘worship leader’.  Let’s “open up the doors and let the music play” – beautiful life-changing music! As we sing together, as we listen and be moved together, let the Holy Spirit be your sheet music. It’s worship after all.

But also sit together, make peace, pray together, sing: It’s worship after all.

Take and eat the body He gave for us, the blood spilt for us. Be reminded that God has given us bodies of our own to give. It’s worship after all.

Hear the Word of God, learn, think, digest, respond. It’s worship after all.

Let our worship be seen, tasted, heard, and lived together and as we go out into the world. If ever I deserve the title of ‘worship leader’ I pray that its because I actually live this way.

Not because I play the acoustic guitar.

Elias Dummer

Posts Google+

As 1/4th of the Juno and Covenant Award winning band The City Harmonic Elias has traveled the world to worship alongside churches and Christians of all kinds. He is passionate about faith, ideas, music, culture and the Church, writing and songwriting, worship leading, and all of the ways they collide. Though originally from Hamilton (Ontario, Canada) Elias now lives in Nashville, TN with his wife Meaghan, four kids and a cat who is presently missing (having not come back the very next day).

4 responses to Don’t Call Me A Worship Leader

  1. Beautifully written and dead on spot!

    So many days as I play my guitar by myself in late evenings, I am reminded of how I don’t live my life fully in a matter that Glorifies God.
    Your article speaks so clearly about how worship is ” The Whole Package” or should be.
    I have found myself many time as I drive to a church that I have been invited to lead worship, stopping on the side of the road and reflecting on how really I live my life and enter serious conversation with God about it.
    It seems that I cannot lead people in truly worshipping God if I’m not in line with God!
    Thank you for this article

  2. In my opinion, “The main role of a “worship leader” or a person that encourages others to get closer to Jesus in a service, in my opinion, before leading others, we need to lead our own hearts to Christ” starting at home and then the world.

  3. This is so true! Worship in todays Christianity is in a downward spiral of a mere divine & religious entertainment & a “feel-good” experience. I wish people see this truth and rise up and draw closer to God. Praise the Lord!!

  4. It was those last few sentences that summed it up for me. I do use the title worship leader to describe my role, and I just happen to include music in some of how I lead worship. But the musical part is pointless if it is not congruent with the rest of my life. I am aware that as a worship leader, I am to lead by example. And, really, aren’t all believers called to such a lifestyle?